Opened 18 years ago
Closed 16 years ago
#2498 closed defect (fixed)
MythTV doesn't play mpeg2 with repeated fields correctly
Reported by: | Owned by: | Janne Grunau | |
---|---|---|---|
Priority: | minor | Milestone: | 0.21 |
Component: | mythtv | Version: | head |
Severity: | medium | Keywords: | |
Cc: | Ticket locked: | no |
Description
There are a handfull of channels I view which ever since I started using Myth haven't played correctly. Video and audio start out synced then video slows down and becomes unsynced for several seconds then caches up quickly.
I can provide a video sample if needed.
Attachments (1)
Change History (12)
comment:2 Changed 17 years ago by
Version: | 0.20 → head |
---|
I believe this is a problem with support for frame repeats which is discussed here http://forum.doom9.org/showthread.php?t=119242&page=2[[BR]]
Here is a quote from the forum:
harissa is right. I think it is something else, something real simple.[[BR]] I believe that the RFF flags are being used for frame repeats rather than field repeats.[[BR]] That makes perfectly good sense given that the output is supposed to be progressive: 720P.[[BR]] That causes a big problem for DGMPGDec, because it supports only field repeats.[[BR]] I'll have to add support for frame repeats. I will verify my theory in the debugger today but it's the only plausible theory that fits the known facts.[[BR]] My successful encode working with that theory also tends to corroborate it.[[BR]] But I want to see the MPEG syntax in the debugger. As to why there are patches of frame repeats mixed with non-repeated sections, I do not know, but at least I know how to fix the D2V process for streams like these. EDIT: Theory confirmed in the debugger (RFF plus progressive_sequence = 1)!
I think it's some sort of new thing broadcasters are using for some reason so support seems to be limited at this point.
However, after reading the topic I have been able to use VirtualDub?-MPEG2 to convert those recordings to Xvid without any sync issues.
comment:3 Changed 17 years ago by
Resolution: | → invalid |
---|---|
Status: | new → closed |
This is something that has to be fixed in ffmpeg.
Have you checked that this isn't fixed there yet?
When this is fixed in ffmpeg please reopen this ticket; we'll sync it into MythTV's copy of ffmpeg.
comment:4 follow-up: 5 Changed 17 years ago by
Resolution: | invalid |
---|---|
Status: | closed → reopened |
I just compiled/installed the latest mplayer snapshot 2007-01-16 "dev-SVN-r21937-3.4.4" on my MythTV box and the recordings in question seem to playback perfectly.
Since both mplayer and mythtv use ffmpeg's mpeg2 codec,
I would assume updating the mpeg2 codec would fix this issue.
So I guess that would mean that it's time to sync up to the latest ffmpeg?
If this isn't enough I'm not sure what to look for because I don't really understand what happened to the video.
The ffmpeg change log is located here in case you know what to look for: http://ffmpeg.mplayerhq.hu/changelog.html
comment:5 Changed 17 years ago by
Replying to DannyCan@gmail.com:
I just compiled/installed the latest mplayer snapshot 2007-01-16 "dev-SVN-r21937-3.4.4" on my MythTV box and the recordings in question seem to playback perfectly.
Have you used -demuxer lavf with mplayer?
Since both mplayer and mythtv use ffmpeg's mpeg2 codec,
That not true. mplayer has its own demuxer and uses by default libmpeg2.
I would assume updating the mpeg2 codec would fix this issue.
No, it's not an issue in the mpeg codec but a demuxer bug. My ffplay from 2006-10-16 plays the sample from ticket #2737 fine but my player snapshot from the same date plays the video too fast with -demuxer lavf. So I'm not sure if a ffmpeg resync will help.
comment:6 Changed 17 years ago by
Not a ffmpeg issue. ffplay from 6051 (our last resync) works fine.
comment:7 Changed 17 years ago by
Well janne, I'm at a loss because I compiled the latest ffmpeg on my desktop and ffplay played the movie fine too. So it must be something else.
Or maybe the ffmpeg demuxer DOES have a problem with this and the effect isn't being noticed outside of mythtv somehow.
I hope someone finds the problem before the next release.
comment:8 Changed 17 years ago by
Milestone: | unknown → 0.21 |
---|---|
Owner: | changed from Isaac Richards to Janne Grunau |
Status: | reopened → new |
after ffmpeg resync to r7591 the problem remains but the video is only 3-4 frames ahead.
comment:9 Changed 17 years ago by
So you tested the latest ffmpeg using ffplay?
mru from the #ffmpeg irc channel said this:
frame repeats are for the decoder to handle, not the demuxer iirc it sets a flag in the returned AVFrame the calling app can deal with it as it wishes
So the problem is with another part of mythtv.
comment:10 Changed 17 years ago by
Summary: | DVB: 720p mpeg2 doesn't play correctly → MythTV doesn't play mpeg2 with repeated fields correctly |
---|
comment:11 Changed 16 years ago by
Resolution: | → fixed |
---|---|
Status: | new → closed |
remaining issue seems to be the same as in #4621, closing this ticket as fixed
From the frontend.. sync errors repeat continously.